The best setpoint strategy for a heat pump in Maine is simple: pick a comfortable temperature, usually around 68°F, run the unit in Heat mode, and leave it there. Big overnight drops and constant tweaking tend to make a heat pump work harder in the morning, not less. This guide covers the number to choose, the rare cases where a small setback makes sense, and how auxiliary heat and sleep modes fit in.
TL;DR
- Start at 68°F, a typical winter comfort setpoint according to NYSERDA. Adjust by a degree or two for comfort.
- Hold it steady. Efficiency Maine's guidance is to set it and forget it, because overnight setbacks will not save money with a heat pump.
- If you must set back, keep it to a few degrees, and bring it back up slowly.
- Use Heat mode in winter, not Auto, so the unit never switches to cooling on a mild day.
- Frequent backup (auxiliary) heat is usually a sign to look at your setpoint habits and your system's sizing.
Table of Contents
- What temperature to set a heat pump in winter
- Why steady beats a nighttime setback
- Why ductless units may need a higher setting
- Use Heat mode, not Auto
- Auxiliary heat and your setpoint
- Night mode and sleep mode
- A sample Maine setpoint plan
- Settings are only half the picture
- Our perspective
- Get the system and the upkeep right
- FAQ
- Sources
What temperature to set a heat pump in winter
Start at 68°F. NYSERDA lists 68°F in winter and 75°F in summer as typical comfort setpoints for air source heat pumps. That is a starting point, not a rule. Some households are happier at 66°F, others at 70°F.
Two things are worth knowing before you pick a number:
- Every degree costs something. A 1978 study of a severe northern climate (Minneapolis) found roughly 4% seasonal energy savings per °F of setpoint reduction. That figure is old and comes from a different system generation, so treat it as a sense of scale. Still, the direction holds: a lower steady setpoint uses less energy than a higher one.
- Warmer than you need is wasted heat. Choose the lowest temperature at which everyone is comfortable in normal clothes, then stop adjusting.
If you are asking whether 73°F is too warm: it is not unsafe, but it sits well above the typical 68°F winter figure. Expect it to show up on your electric bill, since in a Maine winter the heat pump is running a lot of hours.
Why steady beats a nighttime setback
With a gas furnace or oil boiler, turning the thermostat down at night is a familiar way to cut fuel use. A heat pump behaves differently. It delivers heat gradually and efficiently at a modest output. Ask it to recover several degrees quickly and it has to ramp up hard.
The official guidance in the Northeast is consistent on this:
- NYSERDA says heat pumps are most efficient at a steady temperature, and that lowering the setpoint by 3°F or more can trigger inefficient catch-up and increase costs.
- Efficiency Maine advises that turning the heat pump down while you are away or asleep may use more energy, because the system must work harder to come back.
- NEEP's homeowner guide says deep setbacks may cost energy and money, and recommends avoiding frequent thermostat changes and turning units on and off to control temperature.
What a hard morning recovery looks like
When the setpoint jumps up in the morning, the heat pump runs at high output for a stretch to close the gap. On a 5°F Maine morning, high output is the point where the unit is already close to its limits. If the gap is big enough, a system with electric backup may bring that on too, which is the most expensive heat in the house. That is the main reason a setback that looks thrifty can backfire.
When a small setback can make sense
Some guidance allows a modest setback. The City of Portland, Oregon, in its ductless installation checklist, says not to exceed four degrees of nighttime setback. Energy Trust of Oregon says to turn the thermostat down no more than three degrees at night with a heat pump. Those are milder climates than Maine, so for our winters, the stricter end of the advice is the safer one.
If you want to try a setback anyway:
- Keep it to 2 to 3°F.
- Raise the setpoint slowly in the morning, a few degrees over time, rather than in one jump. NYSERDA specifically advises raising it gradually.
- Watch whether backup heat starts running. If it does, drop the setback.
- Consider a thermostat with adaptive recovery. The Building America Solution Center explains that these start early and ramp gradually, so the heat pump handles the recovery and auxiliary electric resistance heat is minimized.
An adaptive-recovery thermostat only works if it is compatible with your equipment, so ask your installer before buying one.
Why ductless units may need a higher setting
Most ductless indoor units sit high on a wall. Heat rises, and the unit reads the temperature right where it is mounted. That can leave the floor cooler than the display suggests.
Efficiency Maine notes that you may need to set the temperature higher than you would on a traditional wall thermostat to feel comfortable. NYSERDA puts a number on it: set it 1 to 2°F higher than your previous furnace or boiler setting for floor-level comfort.

So if your old oil thermostat was at 68°F and the room feels cool at 68°F on the heat pump remote, try 69 or 70°F. Then leave it alone for a few days before judging. Moving it up and down every evening defeats the purpose.
Use Heat mode, not Auto
This is the easiest setting to fix and one of the most often missed. Auto mode lets the unit decide between heating and cooling. On a mild winter afternoon, that can mean the system flips to cooling.
- NYSERDA says to set the mode to Heat in winter and Cool in summer, instead of Auto, which can switch at the wrong times and waste energy.
- Efficiency Maine gives the same advice, to avoid accidental cooling on mild winter days.
Switch to Heat in the fall, and switch to Cool in the late spring. Putting a reminder in your calendar is enough.
Auxiliary heat and your setpoint
If your system has electric backup, your setpoint strategy and your backup heat are linked. Carrier's guide explains that auxiliary heat is a secondary stage that engages when the heat pump cannot close the gap to your target in a reasonable time, and that it can trigger when the indoor temperature falls 2 to 3 degrees below setpoint. It turns off once the room approaches the target.
That has practical consequences:
- A deep setback can open the gap that calls for backup heat. Another reason to hold steady.
- Raising the setpoint in big jumps does the same thing. Move it a degree or two at a time.
- Lockout settings matter. Carrier notes that a thermostat can include an auxiliary lockout temperature that keeps backup heat from turning on when the weather outside is mild. Where to set it in Maine depends on your equipment, and we cover it in our guide to the heat pump lockout temperature.
Auxiliary heat and emergency heat are not the same thing, and mixing them up gets expensive. Our explainer on auxiliary heat vs. emergency heat walks through the difference.
If backup heat runs often even with a steady setpoint, the cause may be sizing rather than settings. A system chosen from a real heat-loss calculation is far less likely to lean on backup. A guide on choosing a cold-climate heat pump makes the same point about asking for a Manual J load calculation. Our own notes on capacity at 5°F explain what to expect when the temperature drops.
Night mode and sleep mode
Many readers ask what night mode or sleep mode does on a heat pump. The answer depends on the brand, so check your manual. Two examples:
- GE Appliances' manual says the SLEEP function automatically adjusts the set temperature for a comfortable sleeping environment, works in Cool, Heat and Auto, and shuts the unit off after 8 hours of run time if no other command is chosen.
- Other brands use a timed program that gently lowers the heating setpoint by a degree or two.
That second behavior is small enough to be harmless in most cases. The problem is the end of the cycle. If a sleep mode ends by shutting the unit off, as in the GE manual, the house cools through the cold part of the night and the unit has to recover in the morning. In a Maine winter, that is the opposite of steady.
Our advice: for winter, leave sleep mode off unless your manual confirms it only trims the setpoint by a degree or two and does not turn the unit off. If a room is too warm under blankets, lower the steady setpoint by one degree and keep it there around the clock.
A sample Maine setpoint plan
Here is a starting plan you can adjust after a week of use.
| Situation | Suggested approach |
|---|---|
| Normal winter day, home or away for a few hours | Hold one setpoint, around 68°F to start |
| Ductless unit mounted high, floor feels cool | Try 1 to 2°F above your old furnace setting |
| Sleeping | Hold steady, or a setback of 2 to 3°F at most |
| Morning warm-up after any setback | Raise it a few degrees at a time, not all at once |
| Mild day in winter | Stay in Heat mode, never Auto |
| Away for a long trip | Lower the setpoint modestly, not to a deep setback, and ask your installer what is safe for your system and your pipes |
| Backup heat running often | Check for deep setbacks and big jumps, then talk to a professional about sizing |
Make one change at a time and give it a few days. A heat pump responds slowly by design, so judging a new setting after an hour leads to second guessing.
Settings are only half the picture
A good setpoint can only do so much if the unit is dirty or the system is undersized. Dirty filters and coils reduce airflow and make the unit work harder to hold the same temperature. If the unit stops delivering the heat you expect, our checklist for a heat pump that is not heating covers what to check before you call anyone. If cool air comes out at the start of a cycle, see why a few minutes of cold air is normal in cold climates.

For background on how these systems work in our winters, see our guide to cold climate heat pumps in Maine.
Our perspective
We see the same pattern in Maine homes every winter. A homeowner switches from oil or a boiler, keeps the old habit of cranking the thermostat down at night, and then wonders why the electric bill and the backup heat run higher than expected.
Our view is that setpoint strategy starts before the thermostat. It starts with a system sized from a real heat-loss calculation for the home, because a unit that is properly sized for the house holds a steady temperature without straining. That is why we design for Maine's cold, down to −22°F and below, rather than for an average winter.
The second half is upkeep. A proactive maintenance routine keeps coils and filters clean so the heat pump can hold your setpoint with less effort. That is the idea behind our care plans.
Pick a number, hold it, and let a well-designed system do its work.
John
Get the system and the upkeep right
If your heat pump struggles to hold its setpoint, we can help. We install and replace cold-climate heat pumps sized from heat-loss calculations, and we confirm service by ZIP code before any appointment or payment. Our services page lists installation, change-outs, and preventive maintenance, and a one-time deep cleaning starts at $249.

For ongoing care, the Annual Cleaning Plan is $219 per year, and the Maine Heat Pump Care Plan is $319 per year. Planning a new install? Start with our installation planning page.
FAQ
What is the best temperature to set a heat pump to in winter?
Start at 68°F, which NYSERDA lists as a typical winter comfort setpoint. If your indoor unit is mounted high, you may need 1 to 2°F more to feel comfortable at floor level. Once you find a comfortable number, leave it there.
Should I turn my heat pump down at night?
Generally no. Efficiency Maine says turning a heat pump down while you sleep may use more energy, because the unit works harder to recover. If you do set back, keep it to a few degrees and raise it slowly in the morning.
What is a good heat pump setting for sleep mode?
For winter, a steady setpoint is better than a timed sleep program. Sleep modes vary by brand, and some shut the unit off after a set number of hours, as GE's manual describes. Read your manual before using one in cold weather.
Why does my heat pump use backup heat in cold weather?
Backup heat engages when the heat pump cannot close the gap between room temperature and your setpoint quickly enough. Deep setbacks and large setpoint jumps make that gap bigger. If it happens even with steady settings, have a professional check sizing and controls.
Should I use Auto mode in winter?
No. NYSERDA and Efficiency Maine both recommend Heat mode in winter, because Auto can switch to cooling on a mild day and waste energy.
Sources
- NYSERDA, Air Source Heat Pump fact sheet
- Efficiency Maine, Heat Pump User Tips
- NEEP, Getting The Most Out of Your Heat Pump
- Portland Bureau of Planning and Sustainability, ductless heat pump checklist
- Energy Trust of Oregon, cold-weather tips
- OSTI, energy savings through thermostat setback
- Building America Solution Center, Thermostat Controls
- Carrier, What is a Heat Pump Thermostat?
- GE Appliances, system manual
- Guide to choosing a cold-climate heat pump
